Computer Rating System Prediction Results for Pro football (NFL)

2010 Season Totals

Through
Rank System Pct. Correct Against Spread Absolute Error Bias Mean Square Error games suw sul atsw atsl
1Eric Hollobaugh0.604320.5882410.3521-0.11700176.5970013984558056
2Cover810.660470.5123210.5856-0.31110190.824002151427310499
3Bihl Rankings0.646340.5652210.77752.44270204.25200164106589170
4Line (opening)0.657890.5257710.80080.74440194.669002661759110292
5Game Time Decision0.640450.5240010.81081.33000194.3450026717196131119
6Line (updated)0.6441910.82020.70790194.6100026717295
7Computer Adjusted Line0.640450.5061710.82400.69290194.19100267171964140
8John Coffey0.633510.5294110.83391.30480201.93200191121709988
9Michael Robert Ratings0.636700.5115410.83620.35150198.0230026717097133127
10Sagarin Predictive0.621720.5538510.98450.80510200.69500267166101144116
11David and Pasteur0.621720.5173710.99221.06030199.62000267166101134125
12System Median0.617980.4922511.01460.69920199.09800267165102127131
13Wunderdog Sports0.621720.4585211.01500.11610197.67400267166101105124
14Sagarin0.617980.4961511.01750.72560200.68500267165102129131
15System Average0.625470.4923111.02590.61650199.31500267167100128132
16Pigskin Index0.617980.4938311.05611.21430199.55900267165102120123
17Dokter Entropy0.629210.4594611.06840.96460199.2800026716899119140
18Massey Ratings0.617980.4980711.07480.86170199.67400267165102129130
19Covers.com0.614230.5156311.08770.96370206.09500267164103132124
20Ashby AccuRatings0.632960.4831911.09741.21790201.5080026716998115123
21Austin Sports0.629630.6000011.14230.94190218.176001891197011174
22Sonny Moore0.588010.4923111.14650.43590210.42500267157110128132
23Hank Trexler0.603000.4959711.1498-0.39330201.90600267161106123125
24Jim Armstrong0.629210.4728711.15731.28720202.6390026716899122136
25Scoring Effeciency0.610490.5269211.16461.05190206.02100267163104137123
26Atomic Football0.621210.4549011.17630.54990202.11400264164100116139
27ARGH Power Ratings0.620000.4978011.1970-0.16300203.3550025015595113114
28Nutshell Girl0.614230.4594611.20570.79980205.06500267164103119140
29PerformanZ Ratings0.606740.5444011.22540.20290204.27500267162105141118
30Schmidt Comp. Ratings0.591760.4807711.31371.10060208.59100267158109125135
31Reistertown Index0.610490.5179311.31830.30720206.72400267163104130121
32Brian Gabrielle0.588540.4970811.32031.37260214.29300192113798586
33Upset Report0.617980.5387811.3933-0.13480209.73000267165102132113
34Sportrends0.603000.5220911.40451.38260212.08300267161106130119
35Kasulis Enhanced Spread0.606740.4648411.40500.10340209.23300267162105119137
36Tom Benson0.437500.3571411.4088-10.73250199.91800167959
37Sagarin Elo0.617980.4692311.42220.61310208.76300267165102122138
38JFM Power Ratings0.621720.4500011.45291.07080208.26700267166101117143
39Nationalsportsrankings0.589840.4556511.46200.97270212.54200256151105113135
40CPA Rankings0.617980.5000011.46870.39930217.52900267165102130130
41Stephen Kerns0.625470.5000011.4734-0.05170211.25300267167100129129
42Stat Fox0.629210.4146311.48691.24000211.2880026716899102144
43Nutshell Combo0.610490.4341111.49810.78580209.00800267163104112146
44PickingPros.com0.625570.5441911.49930.31510221.178002191378211798
45Kambour Rating0.621720.5153811.52310.54670214.61600267166101134126
46Steven Jens0.578950.4488211.53761.24970213.91400266154112114140
47Yarnell0.643980.5376311.54571.27520214.351001911236810086
48CPA Retro Rankings0.632960.4423111.55210.25000219.6540026716998115145
49Pythagorean Ratings0.565540.5269211.55440.32310224.84100267151116137123
50Dunkel Index0.584270.4500011.55740.19930217.69100267156111117143
51Roger Johnson0.593610.5071111.61700.40740226.2280021913089107104
52Beck Elo0.573030.4807711.61940.44040219.43400267153114125135
53Brent Craig0.593980.4803111.64691.18080220.4430013379546166
54Logistic Regression0.535580.5019611.6609-0.32490221.94200267143124128127
55Pat Laffaye0.588010.5193811.79590.41540229.11800267157110134124
56Strengthranking.com0.593630.5122011.81270.70460220.38400251149102126120
57Least Squares0.588010.5057911.8537-0.28480232.07000267157110131128
58NFL Pickles0.610490.5136211.9532-0.70300228.06300267163104132125
59Least Abs. Val Reg0.599250.4594611.9852-0.39530236.49600267160107119140
60NutShell Sports0.599250.4324312.06840.72040227.22000267160107112147
61RP Excel0.554310.4782612.14981.28840245.18500267148119121132
62Dwiggins0.586960.4864912.25000.58140240.7040023013595108114
63What If Sports0.580520.4136512.2584-0.61800234.40000267155112103146
64Lee Burdorf0.565540.4863812.29781.18620243.81500267151116125132
65LS - w/ team HFA0.531840.4505912.4948-0.52880243.37200267142125114139
66YourLinx0.588010.4346213.17810.38160270.06400267157110113147
pct correct = percent straight up picking winners
against spread =  percent against the midweek line
absolute error = average(prediction - actual result)
bias = absolute value(prediction - actual result)
mean square error = absolute error squared
games collected
suw = straight up wins
sul = straight up losses
atsw = against the spread wins
atsl = against the spread losses