Computer Rating System Prediction Results for Pro football (NFL)

2023 Season Totals

Through 2023-09-25
Rank System Pct. Correct Against Spread Absolute Error Bias Mean Square Error games suw sul atsw atsl
1Roundtable0.437500.1875019.4375-3.31250511.252001679313
2Dan Hanson0.625000.4285711.4650-2.57190237.299003220121216
3Dunkel Index0.625000.4444410.3003-1.41530234.029003220121215
4ARGH Power Ratings0.708330.5227310.42710.00000214.432004834142321
5Talisman Red0.687500.5348810.45521.05270210.744004833152320
6Laffaye RWP0.687500.5909110.68382.28040217.449004833152618
7Logistic Regression0.666670.4772711.18210.04330225.531004832162123
8Turnover Adj. regression0.666670.6363610.03810.58690190.188004832162816
9PerformanZ Ratings0.666670.5454510.09670.88790204.705004832162420
10FF-Winners0.645830.4722210.72920.85420212.506004831171719
11Lou St. John0.625000.4772710.71101.79900208.793004830182123
12Least Squares0.625000.5454510.46671.20540201.180004830182420
13TeamRankings.com0.625000.5116310.47291.13130206.374004830182221
14Massey Ratings0.625000.4545510.47650.38480208.115004830182024
15RP Excel0.625000.6136412.39582.18750240.796004830182717
16System Median0.625000.4615410.61001.35290208.071004830181821
17Sagarin Points0.625000.4186010.86461.30380216.640004830181825
18Sagarin Rating0.625000.4318210.97601.50100218.112004830181925
19Pi-Rate Ratings0.604170.5909110.24171.92500194.357004829192618
20Dwiggins0.604170.4318213.65425.04580341.428004829191925
21Stephen Kerns0.604170.5454511.02291.48540218.176004829192420
22Sagarin Recent0.604170.4318211.01871.61830217.152004829191925
23Donchess Inference0.604170.5227310.83131.44380221.380004829192321
24Computer Adjusted Line0.604170.4482810.45830.83330207.725004829191316
25Pi-Rate Mean0.604170.5681810.27081.97500195.374004829192519
26Line (Midweek)0.6041710.38540.80210206.84600482919
27Pi-Rate Bias0.604170.5581410.40421.99580195.336004829192419
28LS - w/ team HFA0.604170.5227310.42061.14730190.445004829192321
29ESPN FPI0.604170.4772710.68040.48540213.748004829192123
30Line (updated)0.604170.4482810.43750.75000207.759004829191316
31System Average0.583330.4772710.57691.51400207.367004828202123
32Points Per Game0.583330.5227314.94500.80710391.909004828202321
33Versus Sports Simulator0.583330.5454511.51811.66190240.475004828202420
34Cleanup Hitter0.583330.4523811.11481.76060215.164004828201923
35Sagarin Golden Mean0.583330.3863611.08651.43690222.136004828201727
36Dokter Entropy0.583330.5454510.87750.85670217.863004828202420
37Stat Fox0.562500.5714310.52132.39620205.322004827212418
38Sonny Moore0.562500.5909110.53061.24560204.816004827212618
39Least Abs. Val Reg0.562500.5952410.66900.93440200.367004827212517
40Game Time Decision0.562500.3250011.37502.50040222.121004827211327
41Scoring Effeciency0.543480.3571412.20831.23650263.031004625211527
42Ashby AccuRatings0.541670.5128210.79251.29250217.306004826222019
43Pigskin Index0.541670.4871811.14602.60440211.548004826221920
44Daniel Curry Index0.541670.4545511.67560.51440236.716004826222024
45Pythagorean Ratings0.541670.4772713.09461.25370283.796004826222123
46Line (opening)0.520830.4634111.05210.57290222.311004825231922
47Odds Shark0.489360.3720912.55534.94260271.488004723241627
48Beck Elo0.479170.3409111.48252.82750230.265004823251529
pct correct = percent straight up picking winners
against spread =  percent against the midweek line
absolute error = average(prediction - actual result)
bias = absolute value(prediction - actual result)
mean square error = absolute error squared
games collected
suw = straight up wins
sul = straight up losses
atsw = against the spread wins
atsl = against the spread losses